As 2026 approaches, many Ontario homeowners are asking: should we renovate the house we have — or relocate to a different property? With high mortgage rates, shifting supply, and evolving family needs, the answer depends on your home’s condition, goals, and what the market looks like now [1][6].

Why 2025‑2026 Is a Unique Moment to Reconsider Your Home

Recent market dynamics — including price softening in some regions, caution among buyers, and ongoing rate pressure — have altered the renovation vs move equation for many Ontarians [0][9].

Homeowners are seeing value in improving their existing home rather than facing high costs and uncertainty of relocating. Rising renovation activity is reported across the province, especially among those wanting to update or expand living space without taking on a new mortgage [6][4].

When Renovating Tends to Make More Sense Than Moving

• Your home has good “bones”: If the structure is solid, roof, foundation and major systems are in decent shape — upgrades like kitchens, bathrooms, finishing basements can give more usable space without the cost of buying new [9][4].
• You love your neighbourhood, schools or local community: Renovating means you keep the lifestyle, commute, social ties — which can be hard to replicate when moving [9].
• Costs of moving are steep: Sale fees, land transfer costs, higher mortgages, and moving expenses often add up. For many, renovation offers better value than relocating [9][3].
• You want to upgrade for comfort, not just resale: Renovations — like extra bedrooms, energy‑efficiency upgrades, basement suites — improve daily living quality, especially if you plan to stay long‑term [11][6].
• Market conditions make resale gains uncertain: In cooling or buyer‑leaning markets, paying heavy renovation costs hoping to flip value may not pay off — staying put and renovating often offers safer returns [0][12].

When Relocating Might Be the Better Option

Of course, renovation is not always the best choice. Sometimes, relocating makes more sense — especially when the changes needed are extensive or the lifestyle goals have shifted [9][8].

• You need significantly more space: If your current lot or layout cannot support expansion, or renovation would cost nearly as much as buying an appropriately sized home, relocation makes more sense [9][12].
• Your home needs major structural repairs or updates: Roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical or major code issues can make renovation cost‑prohibitive. In such cases, starting fresh may be safer [9]
• You want a different neighbourhood or lifestyle: Proximity to work, schools, amenities, commute times — if these have changed, moving may offer better long‑term alignment than renovating.
• Affordability or financing constraints: If renovation costs are high, or if you’re carrying a high‑interest mortgage, relocating (especially if you downsize) might reduce carrying cost or align with financial goals [3][6].

Which Renovations Give the Best Value in Ontario (2025–2026)

Not all renovations are equal — some deliver long‑term value or better living comfort, while others may not justify their cost. The renovations below tend to offer strong outcomes for Ontario homeowners [4][11].

• Basement finishing or legal suites: Adds substantial usable space (or rental potential) at lower cost than buying larger homes. Great for growing families or investors [5][4].
• Kitchen and bathroom updates: Modernizing kitchens or baths boosts livability and resale appeal — often among top‑performing renovation types in resale value [7][9].
• Energy efficiency & envelope upgrades: New windows/doors, insulation, improved heating — appeal to buyers and reduce long‑term utility costs, especially in Ontario’s climate [11][6].
• Flexible layout / additional bedrooms or home‑office space: As working from home and multi‑generational living grow, extra rooms or flexible floorplans add value [6][9].

How to Approach the Decision: a 5‑Step Checklist

Here’s a simple process to help you decide whether to renovate or relocate:

• 1. Assess your home’s condition & capacity to expand: Structure, foundation, lot size, local zoning, and potential renovation costs.
• 2. Clarify what you need vs what you want: More bedrooms? Better layout? Modern finishes? Or a larger yard and new neighbourhood?
• 3. Compare total costs — renovation vs moving: Include renovation cost, realtor fees, land transfer taxes, moving costs, carrying costs under new mortgage, and potential resale value [12][9].
• 4. Factor in timeframe and lifestyle impact: Renovations can be disruptive and may take months; relocation means selling, searching, moving — each has emotional and logistical costs.
• 5. Consider long‑term goals: Are you planning to stay 5–10 years? For long‑term occupancy, a customized renovation often wins. If you anticipate major life changes (job, family size, location), relocation might make sense.

FAQs: Renovate or Relocate — Common Questions Ontarians Ask

1. Is renovating cheaper than moving?
   Often yes — especially when you account for realtor fees, closing costs, land transfer tax, and higher mortgage amount for a new home [9][3].
2. Will renovations pay off if I sell soon after?
   Depends — cosmetic or minimal renovations may recoup less than cost if the market is soft. Focus on value‑adding upgrades (kitchen, bath, energy‑efficiency, layout) for better ROI [7][5].
3. Is moving a better long‑term investment?
   If you need lots more space, want different neighbourhood amenities, or your current home cannot meet future needs — then relocating may offer better long‑term satisfaction.
4. What if my home needs major repairs (roof, foundation, systems)?
   In those cases, renovation costs can be very high, and relocating may be more cost‑effective. Always evaluate structural integrity first [9].
5. How does the 2026 market outlook affect this decision?
   With stability expected but supply tightness looming, holding and renovating may make sense — but if you want larger space or a different market segment, early‑2026 buying could also be strategic.

Sources:

1. TeamKP – Renovate or Sell As‑Is? 2025 ROI Guide
2. SealCo Construction – Renovate, Don’t Relocate (2025)
3. Rob Golfi Real Estate – The Real Costs of Renovating vs Moving in Canada (2025)
4. Energy Kingston – Home Renovation ROI Guide (2025)
5. Multi‑Trade Building Services – Renovating vs Moving (Oct 2025)
6. Royal LePage – Should You Renovate or Move? (2025)
7. Johnson Team Realty – Should You Renovate Before Listing? (2025)
8. Ever After Homes – Remodel, Build New or Move in 2025 (2025)
9. Square One – Move or Renovate Guide (2025)
10. D’Angelo & Sons – 2025 Home Renovation Trends in Ontario (2025)
11. WAHI – Renovating Your Home vs Selling Your Home (2025)

Sanjeevan

CTMO

Sanjeevan Premkumar is the Chief Technology & Marketing Officer at Bridge, specializing in digital strategy and real estate market research. He combines technical insight with a deep understanding of the property sector.

View Author Profile